When looking at the Seasonic Power Supply test results we see two values, wattage
and volt-amps. Since it might not be clear what they measure, here's a brief
overview.
The
volt-amp (VA) value is how much real power is being consumed by the power supply
being tested to provide the wattage (W) value. The higher the VA value is, the
more electricity is being used by the power supply. Because no electrical device
is 100% efficient, there will always be some loss when converting AC to DC. The
closer the Volt-Amps (VA) and Wattage (W) figures are, the more efficient a
power supply is. This is called the Power Factor: Watts / Volt-Amps =
PF.
Since we're testing with a 120W dummy load, the
load on the power supply (wattage) should be as close to this figure as
possible. Anything above this load in apparent power describes the overhead and
wasted energy (given off as heat) for the particular power supply being tested.
For the unloaded tests, the wattage and volt-amp figures should be as close as
possible to one another. The lower the figures are, the less power is being
wasted.Measurements were taken with an Extech 380803 Power
Analyzer.
Seasonic Power Load Tests |
Power Supply
Model |
Wattage |
Test
Type |
Loaded |
Unloaded |
Seasonic SuperTornado |
400 W (A-PFC) |
Active Power |
177 W |
6 W |
Apparent Power |
182 VA |
7 VA |
Vantec iON2 |
350 W |
Active Power |
192 W |
10 W |
Apparent Power |
277 VA |
21 VA |
Antec TruePower 330 |
330 W |
Active Power |
195 W |
22 W |
Apparent Power |
289 VA |
38 VA |
Ultra X-Connect Green UV 500W |
500 W |
Active Power |
193W |
22 W |
Apparent Power |
307 VA |
40 VA |
AOpen Silent Power AO400-12AHN |
400 W |
Active Power |
179W |
9 W |
Apparent Power |
275 VA |
18 VA |
Seasonic S12-430 |
430 W (A-PFC) |
Active Power |
179W |
6W |
Apparent Power |
180VA |
9VA |
PC Power and Cooling Turbo-Cool 510 Express/SLI |
510 W (A-PFC) |
Active Power |
200 W |
29 W |
Apparent Power |
202 VA |
32 VA |
HEC Ace Power 580UB |
580 W |
Active Power |
183 W |
12 W |
Apparent Power |
272 VA |
26 VA |
HEC Win 550UB |
550 W |
Active Power |
184W |
10W |
Apparent Power |
263VA |
22VA |
Akasa PowerPlus AK-P550FF |
550 W (A-PFC) |
Active Power |
194W |
38W |
Apparent Power |
197VA |
40VA |
AOpen Prima Power AO700-12ALN |
700 W (A-PFC) |
Active Power |
172W |
3W |
Apparent Power |
181VA |
9VA |
PC Power & Cooling Turbo-Cool 1KW |
1000 W (A-PFC) |
Active Power |
205W |
25W |
Apparent Power |
207VA |
32VA |
Seasonic S12 600 |
600 W (A-PFC) |
Active Power |
164W |
7W |
Apparent Power |
173VA |
9VA |
Mushkin Enhanced XP-650 |
650 W |
Active Power |
192W |
22W |
Apparent Power |
279VA |
43VA |
Seasonic S12 Energy Plus SS-650HT |
650 W (A-PFC) |
Active Power |
150W |
7W |
Apparent Power |
150VA |
10VA |
Seasonic M12 700W |
700 W (A-PFC) |
Active Power |
161W |
8W |
Apparent Power |
165VA |
11VA |
Corsair HX620W |
620 W (A-PFC) |
Active Power |
171W |
8W |
Apparent Power |
173VA |
12VA |
Zalman
ZM600-HP |
600 W (A-PFC) |
Active Power |
173W |
5W |
Apparent Power |
175VA |
9VA |
HEC Zephyr 650 |
650 W (A-PFC) |
Active Power |
185W |
12W |
Apparent Power |
190VA |
17VA |
GlacialPower GP-PS550BP |
550 W |
Active Power |
178W |
6W |
Apparent Power |
269VA |
17VA |
Cooler Master Real Power Pro 750W |
750 W (A-PFC) |
Active Power |
158W |
6W |
Apparent Power |
163VA |
9VA |
Cooler Master Real Power Pro 750W |
750 W (A-PFC) |
Active Power |
158W |
6W |
Apparent Power |
163VA |
9VA |
Seasonic S12 II
500W |
500W (A-PFC) |
Active Power |
145W |
7W |
Apparent Power |
148VA |
10VA |
Enermax Infiniti
720W |
720W (A-PFC) |
Active Power |
179 W |
12 W |
Apparent Power |
181 VA |
18 VA |
COOLMAX GREEN
POWER CUQ-1200B |
1200W (A-PFC) |
Active Power |
172 W |
9 W |
Apparent Power |
193 VA |
12 VA |
PC Power & Cooling Silencer
750 Quad |
750 (A-PFC) |
Active Power |
168 W |
12 W |
Apparent Power |
175 VA |
15 VA |
Enermax Galaxy
EGX850EWL |
850 W (A-PFC) |
Active Power |
184 W |
11 W |
Apparent Power |
193 VA |
16 VA |
Seasonic M12D 750 |
750W (A-PFC) |
Active Power |
169W |
7W |
Apparent Power |
173VA |
9VA |
Seasonic S12D 850 |
850W (A-PFC) |
Active Power |
148W |
7W |
Apparent Power |
149VA |
10VA |
Seasonic X-750 |
750W (A-PFC) |
Active Power |
139W |
6W |
Apparent Power |
141VA |
8VA |
Seasonic X-460 (SS-460FL) |
460W (A-PFC F3) |
Active Power |
162W |
10W |
Apparent Power |
164VA |
14VA |
Seasonic X-760
(SS-760KM) |
760W (A-PFC F3) |
Active Power |
161W |
6W |
Apparent Power |
164VA |
10VA | |
The Seasonic X-460 power supply uses 162W of power when a 120W power load
is hooked up, which is 74% efficiency at 26% load of its rated 460W power
output. The Seasonic X-460 Fanless is rated for 88.18% efficiency at 20%
load according to 80Plus specs, so the results
we're seeing here are apparently a bit off from the 80 Plus Gold certification. Power factor is 0.98PF.
Unloaded power draw is about 10W, or 14VA for a power factor of 0.75PF.
Conclusions: Fanless for
itself, rest of the computer on its
own
The 460W Seasonic X-460 Fanless is an interesting power supply for a niche section
of DIY computer builders. Used in an appropriately ventilated computer case it opens up
a world of quieter home theatre PCs, or perhaps laboratory or recording
studio environments where noise from traditional power supply fans is unwanted. At
460W, the X-460 is well sized for the power demands of mainstream computer
systems built around
motherboards or processors with integrated graphics, although it does include two PCI Express
auxiliary power connectors for discrete videocards.
The
computer case is
the key variable in the silent computer equation, it's also the hardest for us
to comment or give guidance on.
The reliance on convective cooling means the Seasonic X-460 Fanless power supply is not
suitable for all environments. A climate controlled office is likely fine, a
hot un-airconditioned New York apartment in the middle of a summer heat
wave.... likely not. Similarly, a computer case without any vents above the power
supply, or worse
where the top of the power supply butts up against the metal panels is
simply not going to work here.
Seasonic are pretty vague on what constitutes a "well
designed system chassis," so a certain amount of common sense from the user is required.
Ensure the case has good ventilation above the power supply and sufficient cool
air intake vents below it. It's really a case by case question you'll
have to judge for yourself. But make no mistake, fanless does not mean
silently sealed up
in a closed box. Fanless means increasing the number or size of cooling vents
so natural convection cooling can work.
There is also the rather
tricky question of what to do with all the heat
dumped into the PC chassis by other components; the processor, motherboard VRM,
motherboard chipset, videocard or IGP, hard drives, expansion cards and so
forth. Seasonic have designed the X-460 Fanless to "be responsible for its
own cooling and functionality". Choice words that perhaps don't underscore
this point well enough - the X-460 Fanless power supply is intended to cool
itself and only itself. Most computer
systems rely upon the power supply to exhaust hot air from the top
of the chassis,
draw hot air away from the CPU thermal solution and motherboard's passive VRM heatsinks. What happens when
that active exhaust port is removed?
The best answer we can give is that the Seasonic X-460 Fanless is not designed for
these tasks and by virtue of its ventilation design will not absorb these tasks either. Thus while the
Seasonic X-460 Fanless is built to replace any standard 460W power supply in
terms of power delivery, it's not going to fulfill all the responsibilities
usually associated with an actively cooled PSU in the computer system. It's a
fine point of
distinction, but a crucial one to be aware of should you embark on
a totally fanless computer system build.
In and of itself, Seasonic
have manufactured a very satisfying PSU that's evident the moment you lift it out
of the box. The modular cables are sufficient for its power output, the
build quality is enviable and it produces no noise from fans or humming
capacitors. Retailing for about $160CDN ($160USD, £70 GBP),
the Seasonic X-460 Fanless (SS-460FL) isn't cheap, but is well built, stable
and efficient. It's a harder point to recommend or not, I think in
this case a
fanless power supply is one component best selected by DIY computer builders who
know enough to answer that question themselves.
Find out about this and many other reviews by joining the Weekly PCstats.com Newsletter today!
Catch all of PCSTATS latest reviews right here.
Related Articles
Here are a few other articles that you
might enjoy as well...
- Seasonic X-750 750W 80Plus Gold Power Supply Review
- Seasonic S12D-850 850W Power Supply Review
- Seasonic M12D-750 750W Power Supply Review
- PC
Power & Cooling Silencer 750 Quad 750W PSU Review
- Enermax Galaxy EGX850EWL 850W Modular Power Supply Review
-
Coolmax CUQ-1200B 1200W Power Supply Review
- Enermax Infiniti 720W Power Supply Review
- Seasonic S12-II 500W Power Supply Review
- Cooler Master Real Power Pro 750W Power Supply Review