Diving into the PCMark Vantage HDD test suite reveals
actual MB/s figures that have more bearing than dimensionless values. Across the
board Intel SRT improves responsiveness roughly four-fold. What's interesting
about this benchmark is we can compare Intel SRT in Enhanced mode to Intel SRT
in Maximized mode (slightly more risky where potential data loss is
concerned).
Futuremark PCMark
Vantage - HDD Suite |
Windows Defender: (MB/s) |
Points |
Ranking |
SSD |
153.465 |
|
HDD |
20.466 |
|
HDD + Cache SSD (Enhanced) RUN 1 |
20.237 |
|
HDD + Cache SSD (Enhanced) RUN 2 |
120.669 |
|
HDD + Cache SSD (Enhanced) RUN 3 |
114.189 |
|
HDD + Cache SSD (Maximized) RUN 1 |
20.677 |
|
HDD + Cache SSD (Maximized) RUN 2 |
123.118 |
|
HDD + Cache SSD (Maximized) RUN 3 |
118.959 |
| |
As we saw previously, the ceiling is held by the SSD
system (153.465MB/s) and the floor by the HDD system (20.466MB/s).
In both Intel SRT Enhanced
and Maximized modes, the first benchmark run
comes in at the same level as the HDD system result. Makes sense, right? Windows
7 is installed on the same Western Digital WD740 Raptor hard drive for both the
HDD + Cache SSD system and HDD system.
Once that data is cached on the Intel 311 SSD the
results improve 6x!
The Enhanced mode yields 120MB/s out of the gate while
the Maximized mode is slightly quicker at 123MB/s. Both scenarios drop a bit by
the third benchmark iteration.
Futuremark PCMark
Vantage - HDD Suite |
Gaming: (MB/s) |
Points |
Ranking |
SSD |
145.101 |
|
HDD |
14.064 |
|
HDD + Cache SSD (Enhanced) RUN 1 |
14.693 |
|
HDD + Cache SSD (Enhanced) RUN 2 |
123.917 |
|
HDD + Cache SSD (Enhanced) RUN 3 |
124.048 |
|
HDD + Cache SSD (Maximized) RUN 1 |
14.82 |
|
HDD + Cache SSD (Maximized) RUN 2 |
118.525 |
|
HDD + Cache SSD (Maximized) RUN 3 |
118.916 |
| |
Again, Intel SRT improves the speed to that of near SSD
levels. In this test, Enhanced mode offers somewhat better results than
Maximized....
Futuremark PCMark
Vantage - HDD Suite |
Importing Pictures: (MB/s) |
Points |
Ranking |
SSD |
188.798 |
|
HDD |
37.987 |
|
HDD + Cache SSD (Enhanced) RUN 1 |
32.818 |
|
HDD + Cache SSD (Enhanced) RUN 2 |
145.343 |
|
HDD + Cache SSD (Enhanced) RUN 3 |
145.431 |
|
HDD + Cache SSD (Maximized) RUN 1 |
32.188 |
|
HDD + Cache SSD (Maximized) RUN 2 |
141.487 |
|
HDD + Cache SSD (Maximized) RUN 3 |
133.684 |
| |
Dito. Better overall improvement to 145MB/s this time
around.
Futuremark PCMark
Vantage - HDD Suite |
Windows Vista Startup: (MB/s) |
Points |
Ranking |
SSD |
176.547 |
|
HDD |
19.14 |
|
HDD + Cache SSD (Enhanced) RUN 1 |
25.073 |
|
HDD + Cache SSD (Enhanced) RUN 2 |
118.636 |
|
HDD + Cache SSD (Enhanced) RUN 3 |
118.152 |
|
HDD + Cache SSD (Maximized) RUN 1 |
25.911 |
|
HDD + Cache SSD (Maximized) RUN 2 |
119.452 |
|
HDD + Cache SSD (Maximized) RUN 3 |
123.474 |
| |
Windows Vista start up improves by 6.2x!
Futuremark PCMark
Vantage - HDD Suite |
Editing Videos: (MB/s) |
Points |
Ranking |
SSD |
196.339 |
|
HDD |
47.515 |
|
HDD + Cache SSD (Enhanced) RUN 1 |
45.346 |
|
HDD + Cache SSD (Enhanced) RUN 2 |
91.016 |
|
HDD + Cache SSD (Enhanced) RUN 3 |
92.651 |
|
HDD + Cache SSD (Maximized) RUN 1 |
53.319 |
|
HDD + Cache SSD (Maximized) RUN 2 |
136.343 |
|
HDD + Cache SSD (Maximized) RUN 3 |
137.193 |
| |
Finally a significant difference between Enhanced and
Maximized modes. Intel SRT Enhanced mode bumps the native HDD system from 47MB/s
to 92MB/s, quite good overall. The more aggressive Intel SRT Maximized mode
triples the native HDD system result from 47MB/s to 137MB/s in this test.
If you do a lot of work editing video content, Intel
Smart Response Technology tuned to the Maximized mode may be the best path to
follow ( if your system is data constrained ). Well, installing the operating
system onto a SSD would be the best path, but
adding an SSD cache via Intel SRT certainly speeds things up too.