Corsair TwinX1024-4400PT Platinum Memory Review
Corsair has recently celebrated their
10th anniversary, which is quite a milestone for a memory company! I think it's high level of customer service that sets apart successful companies from
the rest, and a growing trend in this corporate schmooze-fest with consumer loyalty is the manufacturer run support forum. Now, instead of emailing an
anonymous tech support guy the same question a hundred other people have asked,
you can read through a support FAQ, or post a thread in the support
forums and someone will answer. In Corsair's
case, "RAM GUY" dishes out the info and advice on using the companies memory
products.
Imagine if Microsoft had their
own support forums for everyone who ever suffered the rather of the "BSOD"!
Anyway, getting back on topic, today PCstats is testing out a pair
of Corsair's TwinX1024-4400PT dual channel DDR memory. This is the latest memory
from Corsair, and remarkably difficult to get a hold of... even for us.
Apparently, a shortage of good low latency DRAMs has meant that companies are
reserving most of their best memory for you, the consumer. Thanks to Ramstore.ca for hooking us up with these
modules to test.
These two TwinX1024-4400PT Platinum Edition DDR modules
are 512MB in size, and run at 550MHz. This memory isn't as
fancy as the LED-illuminated TwinX1024-4000PRO models PCstats tested previously, but they
are faster. ;)
As you can see Corsair use platinum
coloured aluminum heatspreaders to help keep the memory cool. The heatspreaders do
lower the overall operating temperatures of memory modules a bit, but they do little
to nothing to enhance overclockability. Still, memory heatspreaders protect the DIMM's from physical
damage; I don't know about you, but I've knocked those tiny resistors off a few sticks of memory
in my time.
Each double sided DIMM has sixteen
256Mb DRAMs which give you a total of 512MB of RAM each. Officially the
TwinX4400PT is designed to run on Intel systems (Corsair
state that in their documentation ) and is rated for dual channel configuration at
275 MHz, with 3-4-4-8 memory timings and at a voltage of 2.75V.
Because these
little silver wonders are destined to go right back from where they came, we
were not at liberty to pry the heatspreaders off and take a peak below.
I suspect the TwinX4400PT modules are using Hynix D43 DRAM.... good stuff that
Hynix, it
clocks higher than most any memory we've tested on an Intel
platform.
Overclocking Corsair's XMS4400
Memory:
Ahh sweet overclocking... it's what we all strive for
really, isn't it? Like all high speed memory modules these days, Corsair really
mean it when they say the TwinX4400PT "is best suited for Intel
systems."
The tests began on the Athlon64 test system here, but the memory wouldn't run timings tighter than 3-4-4-8. If
we changed them to anything else, the system refused to POST.... not a good start. Ultimately,
we didn't have much success raising the clock speed of the motherboard either, the maximum
the memory/board would do was a lowly 210 MHz. It shouldn't be much of
a surprise as this Corsair memory as not intended to be used (or overclocked) in an Athlon64
system anyway.
On the
Intel side of the fence things were much different, the TwinX4400PT DIMMs did not like any
timings other than stock, but ran fast. The memory would easily reach 275 MHz with 2.8V,
and yet be prime95 stable.
Odly, 276MHz would cause WindowsXP
to lock up every time. It's a very weird problem and unfortunately we couldn't
find a way around it. Still, 275 MHz FSB is a pretty sweet number. Intel users
will also be happy to hear that the TwinX4400PT had no problems with the 5:4
or 3:2 memory dividers either.
Test System Spec's
|
PCStats Test System Specs: |
processor: |
amd athlon64 3200+ |
clock
speed: |
10 x 200 mhz = 2 ghz 10 x 210 mhz = 2.1 ghz |
motherboards: |
asus k8v-dlx |
videocard: |
asus radeon 9800xt |
memory: |
corsair twinx 4000* ocz pc3200
plat ltd ed. ** corsair twinx 4400pt* |
hard drive:
|
40gb western digital special ed |
cdrom: |
nec 52x cd-rom |
powersupply: |
vantec 400b ion |
software
setup |
windowsxp build 2600 via 4in1 4.51 catalyst 4.2 |
workstation
benchmarks |
sisoft sandra
2003 pcmark2002 pcmark04 3dmark2001se ut2003 | |
|
PCStats Test System #2 Specs: |
processor: |
intel pentium 4 2.4c |
Clock
Speed: |
12 x 200 MHz = 2.4 GHz 12 x 275 MHz = 1.99 GHz
|
Motherboards: |
Abit IC7 MAX3 |
Videocard: |
ATi Radeon 9800XT |
Memory: |
Corsair TwinX 4000* OCZ PC3200
Plat LTD Ed.** Corsair TwinX 4400PT* |
Hard Drive:
|
20GB Western Digital 7200 RPM
HDD |
CDROM: |
NEC 52x CD-ROM |
PowerSupply: |
PC Power & Cooling Turbocool 510 |
Software
Setup |
WindowsXP Build 2600 Intel INF 5.00.1012 Catalyst
4.2 |
Workstation
Benchmarks |
SiSoft Sandra
2003 PCMark2002 PCMark04 3DMark2001SE UT2003 | |
* Memory is running 3-4-4-8
** Memory is running
2-2-2-5