|
With the Intel P35 Express chipset, users have two memory options; DDR2 and DDR3 RAM. The latter is certainly the future-proof option although it is still somewhat costly, while the former is firmly on the road to obsolescence.
80% Rating:
|
|
Home >
Reviews >
Motherboards >
MSI P35 Platinum Combo |
|
|
Motherboard Benchmarks: 3DMark06, Quake 4, FEAR
3DMark06 is
the worldwide standard in advanced 3D game performance benchmarking. A
fundamental tool for every company in the PC industry as well as PC users and
gamers, 3DMark06 uses advanced real-time 3D game workloads to measure PC
performance using a suite of DirectX 9 3D graphics tests, CPU tests, and 3D
feature tests. 3DMark06 tests include all new HDR/SM3.0 graphics tests, SM2.0
graphics tests, AI and physics driven single and multiple cores or processor CPU
tests and a collection of comprehensive feature tests to reliably measure next
generation gaming performance today.
Futuremark 3DMark06
1.0.2 |
Overall: |
Points |
Ranking |
Asus P5NT Deluxe
(NF 780i 333/1066 GF 8800GTS 320MB) |
9612 |
|
MSI P6N Diamond
(NF 680i 333/1066 GF 8800GTS 320MB) |
9566 |
|
Biostar
TF7150V-M7 (GF 7150 333/1066 Onboard GF 7150) |
384 |
|
MSI X48 Platinum
(X48 333/1333) |
9775 |
|
Asus Maximus
Extreme (X38 333/1333) |
9360 |
|
Foxconn
DigitaLife X38A (X38 333/800 DDR2) |
9415 |
|
Foxconn
DigitaLife X38A (X38 333/1333 DDR3) |
9355 |
|
Gigabyte
GA-X38-DQ6 (X38 333/1066) |
9409 |
|
Asus BLITZ
Formula (P35 333/1066) |
9385 |
|
Foxconn MARS (P35
333/1066) |
9230 |
|
MSI P35
Platinum Combo (P35 333/800 DDR2) |
9753 |
|
MSI P35
Platinum Combo (P35 333/1333 DDR3) |
9751 |
|
CPU: |
Points |
Ranking |
Asus P5NT Deluxe
(NF 780i 333/1066 GF 8800GTS 320MB) |
2377 |
|
MSI P6N Diamond
(NF 680i 333/1066 GF 8800GTS 320MB) |
2345 |
|
Biostar
TF7150V-M7 (GF 7150 333/1066 Onboard GF 7150) |
2352 |
|
MSI X48 Platinum
(X48 333/1333) |
2367 |
|
Asus Maximus
Extreme (X38 333/1333) |
2373 |
|
Foxconn
DigitaLife X38A (X38 333/800 DDR2) |
2413 |
|
Foxconn
DigitaLife X38A (X38 333/1333 DDR3) |
2386 |
|
Gigabyte
GA-X38-DQ6 (X38 333/1066) |
2399 |
|
Asus BLITZ
Formula (P35 333/1066) |
2384 |
|
Foxconn MARS (P35
333/1066) |
2344 |
|
MSI P35
Platinum Combo (P35 333/800 DDR2) |
2378 |
|
MSI P35
Platinum Combo (P35 333/1333 DDR3) |
2380 |
| |
3DMark06
results between all platforms are about the same... then again, this test is
more of a videocard benchmark anyway. There is no significant difference between
the two memory types.
Quake 4 is
the latest shooter from ID and is based on the Doom 3 engine. Tweaked to for
more eye candy, Quake 4 promises to be tougher on videocards and systems than
its predecessor was. Quake 4 also does not have a 60 fps limiter like Doom 3,
with the Ultra setting, graphic textures can surpass the 500MB mark! Each test
is run three times and with the third run being recorded.
ID Software Quake 4
1.04 |
LQ 640x480: |
Points |
Ranking |
Asus P5NT Deluxe
(NF 780i 333/1066 GF 8800GTS 320MB) |
221.4 |
|
MSI P6N Diamond
(NF 680i 333/1066 GF 8800GTS 320MB) |
213.7 |
|
Biostar
TF7150V-M7 (GF 7150 333/1066 Onboard GF 7150) |
23.3 |
|
MSI X48 Platinum
(X48 333/1333) |
217.5 |
|
Asus Maximus
Extreme (X38 333/1333) |
221.6 |
|
Foxconn
DigitaLife X38A (X38 333/800 DDR2) |
227.6 |
|
Foxconn
DigitaLife X38A (X38 333/1333 DDR3) |
220.4 |
|
Gigabyte
GA-X38-DQ6 (X38 333/1066) |
215.2 |
|
Asus BLITZ
Formula (P35 333/1066) |
224.5 |
|
Foxconn MARS (P35
333/1066) |
207.1 |
|
MSI P35
Platinum Combo (P35 333/800 DDR2) |
206.7 |
|
MSI P35
Platinum Combo (P35 333/1333 DDR3) |
218 |
|
UQ 1024x768: |
Points |
Ranking |
Asus P5NT Deluxe
(NF 780i 333/1066 GF 8800GTS 320MB) |
205.6 |
|
MSI P6N Diamond
(NF 680i 333/1066 GF 8800GTS 320MB) |
191.6 |
|
Biostar
TF7150V-M7 (GF 7150 333/1066 Onboard GF 7150) |
52.7 |
|
MSI X48 Platinum
(X48 333/1333) |
223.6 |
|
Asus Maximus
Extreme (X38 333/1333) |
208.5 |
|
Foxconn
DigitaLife X38A (X38 333/800 DDR2) |
208.9 |
|
Foxconn
DigitaLife X38A (X38 333/1333 DDR3) |
206.3 |
|
Gigabyte
GA-X38-DQ6 (X38 333/1066) |
206.1 |
|
Asus BLITZ
Formula (P35 333/1066) |
207.9 |
|
Foxconn MARS (P35
333/1066) |
183.7 |
|
MSI P35
Platinum Combo (P35 333/800 DDR2) |
205.06 |
|
MSI P35
Platinum Combo (P35 333/1333 DDR3) |
214.3 |
| |
The MSI P35 Platinum Combo clearly prefers DDR3 memory in
Quake 4.
Sierra FEAR 1.08 |
Source: Sierra |
|
FEAR is
Sierra's latest first person shooter which relies heavily on DirectX 9 features.
With its "Soft Shadows" feature enabled, even the fastest videocards run at a
crawl, FEAR is definitely the new benchmark for future FPS games to follow.
Sierra FEAR 1.08 |
Minimum 640x480: |
Points |
Ranking |
Asus P5NT Deluxe
(NF 780i 333/1066 GF 8800GTS 320MB) |
568 |
|
MSI P6N Diamond
(NF 680i 333/1066 GF 8800GTS 320MB) |
545 |
|
Biostar
TF7150V-M7 (GF 7150 333/1066 Onboard GF 7150) |
145 |
|
MSI X48 Platinum
(X48 333/1333) |
567 |
|
Asus Maximus
Extreme (X38 333/1333) |
563 |
|
Foxconn
DigitaLife X38A (X38 333/800 DDR2) |
575 |
|
Foxconn
DigitaLife X38A (X38 333/1333 DDR3) |
562 |
|
Gigabyte
GA-X38-DQ6 (X38 333/1066) |
554 |
|
Asus BLITZ
Formula (P35 333/1066) |
572 |
|
Foxconn MARS (P35
333/1066) |
551 |
|
MSI P35
Platinum Combo (P35 333/800 DDR2) |
545 |
|
MSI P35
Platinum Combo (P35 333/1333 DDR3) |
554 |
|
Maximum 1024x768: |
Points |
Ranking |
Asus P5NT Deluxe
(NF 780i 333/1066 GF 8800GTS 320MB) |
137 |
|
MSI P6N Diamond
(NF 680i 333/1066 GF 8800GTS 320MB) |
134 |
|
Biostar
TF7150V-M7 (GF 7150 333/1066 Onboard GF 7150) |
3 |
|
MSI X48 Platinum
(X48 333/1333) |
134 |
|
Asus Maximus
Extreme (X38 333/1333) |
124 |
|
Foxconn
DigitaLife X38A (X38 333/800 DDR2) |
130 |
|
Foxconn
DigitaLife X38A (X38 333/1333 DDR3) |
123 |
|
Gigabyte
GA-X38-DQ6 (X38 333/1066) |
124 |
|
Asus BLITZ
Formula (P35 333/1066) |
125 |
|
Foxconn MARS (P35
333/1066) |
126 |
|
MSI P35
Platinum Combo (P35 333/800 DDR2) |
135 |
|
MSI P35
Platinum Combo (P35 333/1333 DDR3) |
134 |
| |
FEAR results also show that games slightly prefer the
lower latencies of DDR2 memory over DDR3. That may change with quad core
processors but then again the software must also support that feature too.
|