OCZ PC4000EL Gold Edition Memory Review
The
memory market
is pretty saturated right now with high speed memory modules from
every corner, and in an attempt to differentiate themselves from their competitors
we've noticed that OCZ have been tightening up their
memory timings just a bit. After all if you're running PC2100 DDR and PC4000
DDR at stock speeds, it really doesn't
make any difference to the computer.... but then if you overclock that is where
speed, and memory timings really come into play. For an illustration of just what we're talking about,
please read through PCstats look at Memory
Latency VS Bandwidth. For the rest of you who
know what tight memory timings can really bring to the table, read
on!
In this
memory review, PCstats is testing out OCZ's
Gold Edition PC4000EL DDR. Each of these PC4000EL modules are 512MB in size, and
since they are destined for dual channel systems, OCZ sell the memory as a pair.
The OCZ PC4000EL DDR is rated to run up to 250 MHz while maintaining
timings of 2.5-4-4-7, at 2.8V. That's not exactly as tight as some other lower speed
modules, but it is better than the 3-4-4-8 timings most other high speed
DIMM's run under.
Officially, OCZ use gold plated copper heat spreaders to
help keep the DIMM's "cool," but as we all know, memory heat spreaders do little
to nothing for memory cooling. What they are good for is protecting the DIMM's from
physical damage.
Under the
armor
OCZ
use Hynix HY5DU56822BT-D43 TSOP-II DRAM in the PC4000EL Gold DIMM's, but
that shouldn't be much of a surprise as most memory manufacturers use the "D43" memory for PC4XXX class memory. Each
DIMM is equipped with sixteen 256Mb DRAM modules, which total 512MB of memory
when things are all said and done.
If you're contemplating buying new
memory for your PC, please keep in mind that the OCZ PC4000EL Gold Dual Channel
memory is intended for the i865PE/i875P Intel
chipsets. OCZ state that
themselves
in the
product description.
Unlike previous OCZ memory we've tested, this
time we agree with their assessment 100%... read on and you'll see
why.
Overclocking
the Golden DIMM
We almost always start with the Athlon64 tests first, just
because it tends to be a little more finicky about what memory it likes. After plugging the memory into the Athlon64
test bed, we opened up the BIOS and configured the first round of tests with lax timings.
This is mainly due to experience with Hynix D43 DRAM in the past which we found to
only work with stock timings.
As we began
to raise the clock speed of the AThlon64 motherboard, the memory quickly
bottomed out at 206 MHz. No matter what we did; lower the memory timings or
raise the voltage, it didn't have any effect.
This isn't all that surprising as virtually all high
speed DIMM's on the market (from various manufacturers) perform poorly on
AthlonXP/Athlon64 based systems which are really driven by tighter memory timings
than anything else.
Moving forward with the Intel tests, I anticipated that the OCZ PC4000EL memory would
handle that task a little better, after all this memory is designed to
run on the Intel platform.
Starting at 200 MHz FSB with a memory
voltage of 2.6V (yes, lower then recommended) we began to push the memory forward. At around 223
MHz it ran into a few problems, but that was solved by increasing the memory voltage
to 2.8V. At that voltage the memory easily passed its theoretical rated speed of
250 MHz FSB and we went from there with the tests at 268MHz
which was nice and stable.
|
PCStats Test System Specs: |
processor: |
amd athlon64 3200+ |
clock
speed: |
10 x 200 mhz = 2 ghz 10 x 206 mhz = 2.06 ghz
|
motherboards: |
asus k8v-dlx |
videocard: |
asus radeon 9800xt |
memory: |
2x 512mb corsair twinx 4000* 2x 512mb ocz pc3200
plat ltd ed. ** 2x 512mb ocz pc4000el gold*** |
hard drive:
|
40gb western digital special ed |
cdrom: |
nec 52x cd-rom |
powersupply: |
vantec 400b ion |
software
setup |
windowsxp build 2600 via 4in1 4.51 catalyst 4.2 |
workstation
benchmarks |
sisoft sandra
2003 pcmark2002 pcmark04 3dmark2001se ut2003 | |
|
PCStats Test System #2 Specs: |
processor: |
intel pentium 4 2.4c |
Clock
Speed: |
10 x 200 MHz = 2 GHz 8.5 x 234 MHz = 1.99 GHz |
Motherboards: |
Abit IC7 MAX3 |
Videocard: |
ATi Radeon 9600 Pro |
Memory: |
2x 512MB Corsair TwinX 4000* 2x 512MB OCZ PC3200
Plat LTD Ed.** 2x 512MB OCZ PC4000EL Gold*** |
Hard Drive:
|
20GB Western Digital 7200 RPM
HDD |
CDROM: |
NEC 52x CD-ROM |
PowerSupply: |
PC Power & Cooling Turbocool 510 |
Software
Setup |
WindowsXP Build 2600 Intel INF 5.00.1012 Catalyst
4.2 |
Workstation
Benchmarks |
SiSoft Sandra
2003 PCMark2002 PCMark04 3DMark2001SE UT2003 | |
* Memory is running 3-4-4-8
** Memory is running
2-2-2-5
*** Memory is running 2.5-4-4-7